Home
News
Do Your Own Taxes or Hire a Professional?
Prev
Small Business Tax Forms: A Practical Guide to the Essential Filings You Need
How Homeownership Changes Your Taxes: A Practical Guide to Deductions and Credits
Next
Do Your Own Taxes or Hire a Professional?

Do Your Own Taxes or Hire a Professional?

Date:

A Practical Guide to Making the Right Choice

Tax season brings a familiar question: should you tackle your taxes yourself or hire someone to do it for you? The answer isn't one-size-fits-all. It depends on your financial situation, complexity, and comfort level with numbers.

Let's explore the pros and cons of both approaches so you can make the best decision for your circumstances.

Common Myths About Tax Filing (Debunked)

Before we dive into the DIY vs. professional debate, let's clear up some widespread misconceptions:

Myth 1: Filing taxes yourself guarantees an audit Not true. The IRS doesn't audit people based on whether they filed their own taxes or used a professional. What matters is accuracy and completeness. A correctly prepared return—regardless of who prepared it—won't trigger an audit just because you did it yourself.

Myth 2: You need to earn a certain amount to file False. If you have any income, you can file a tax return. Many people file specifically to claim refunds or tax credits they're entitled to, even when their income is minimal. You might be sitting on unclaimed tax credits or refunds without realizing it.

Myth 3: You can't e-file if you owe taxes Incorrect. You can e-file your return whether you're expecting a refund or owe money. The filing method doesn't change your tax obligation. If you owe, just pay by the deadline to avoid penalties and interest.

Myth 4: Filing status doesn't really matter This is one of the most costly myths. Choosing the wrong filing status can mean paying significantly more in taxes or missing out on deductions and credits you qualify for. Your filing status directly impacts your tax liability.

DIY Tax Filing: When It Makes Sense

Pros of Filing Your Own Taxes

Lower cost. The most obvious benefit is saving money. Tax preparation software ranges from free to a few hundred dollars, compared to professional fees that often range from $200 to $2,500+.

Complete control. You handle every detail of your return. No surprises, no miscommunications, and you understand exactly what's reported.

Flexibility. Work on your taxes when you want, from anywhere. No scheduling appointments or waiting for someone else's availability.

Privacy. Some people prefer keeping their financial information private, even from professionals.

Learning opportunity. You gain a better understanding of how your taxes work, which can inform financial planning decisions throughout the year.

Best Candidates for DIY Filing

You're a good candidate for handling your own taxes if you:

  • Work as a W-2 employee with straightforward income
  • Have minimal investments or side income
  • Don't own a business or rental properties
  • Have simple deductions (standard deduction is enough for you)
  • Understand basic tax concepts or are willing to learn
  • Have time to dedicate to research and preparation
  • Feel comfortable using tax software or online tools

The Reality of DIY Filing

The accuracy of DIY tax filing depends heavily on:

  1. Complexity. Simple returns are genuinely simple. Complicated situations with multiple income sources, business deductions, or investment income require more expertise.

  2. Available resources. Modern tax software is much better at catching errors than it was years ago. It can flag missing information and mathematical errors before you submit.

  3. Your attention to detail. Even with software, you need to accurately input your information. Garbage in, garbage out applies to taxes.

  4. Your willingness to research. Tax laws change annually. If you're not willing to look up current rules, you might miss opportunities or make mistakes.

Professional Tax Preparation: When It's Worth It

Pros of Hiring a Tax Professional

Expertise. A trained tax professional knows current tax laws, deductions, and credits that might not be obvious to the average person. This expertise often pays for itself.

Complexity handling. If your situation is complicated, a professional can navigate it more efficiently and accurately than you can.

Deduction maximization. Tax professionals know which deductions apply to your situation. They often find savings you wouldn't have discovered on your own.

Time savings. You don't have to spend hours learning tax software, gathering documents, and preparing your return. The professional handles it.

Liability protection. If your return is audited, having a professional who prepared it provides some level of support and accountability.

Ongoing advice. Good tax professionals offer guidance throughout the year to help you plan and minimize taxes strategically.

Best Candidates for Professional Filing

You should consider hiring a professional if you:

  • Are self-employed or own a business
  • Have significant investment income or rental property income
  • Own multiple properties or have complex real estate situations
  • Have complicated family situations (second marriages, dependents with specific needs, etc.)
  • Have high income with multiple income sources
  • Have significant charitable donations or other itemized deductions
  • Have business expenses that require detailed tracking and documentation
  • Feel overwhelmed or confused by tax concepts
  • Have been audited in the past
  • Have significant life changes (marriage, business sale, major inheritance, etc.)

Filing Jointly vs. Separately: Understanding the Difference

If you're married, you need to decide whether to file jointly or separately. Here's what you should know:

Filing Jointly

Advantages:

  • Larger standard deduction (nearly double the single rate)
  • Access to more tax credits and deductions (like the Earned Income Credit)
  • Usually results in lower overall tax liability
  • Simpler paperwork with one combined return

Disadvantages:

  • Joint liability means you're both responsible for the accuracy of the return
  • One spouse's tax issues can affect the other

Filing Separately

Advantages:

  • Protects one spouse's refund if the other owes taxes
  • Separates tax liability between spouses
  • Can be advantageous in specific situations with high state taxes

Disadvantages:

  • Higher combined tax bill in most cases
  • You lose access to certain credits and deductions
  • More paperwork (two returns instead of one)
  • Greater opportunity for errors

The general rule: Most married couples benefit from filing jointly. Filing separately only makes sense in specific situations, usually with professional guidance.

Electronic Filing vs. Paper Filing

This is straightforward: e-file your taxes.

Why E-filing is Better

Speed. E-filed returns reach the IRS in minutes, not weeks. Refunds process faster (typically 21 days or less with direct deposit).

Accuracy. E-filing software catches mathematical errors and missing information before you submit. Paper filing gives you no such safety net.

Security. E-filing is encrypted and protected. Your sensitive financial information is safer than mailing paper documents through the postal system.

Confirmation. You get immediate confirmation that the IRS received your return. Paper filing leaves you wondering for weeks.

Fewer delays. Lost mail, illegible handwriting, and processing errors are eliminated with e-filing.

Updated filing. If you need to file an amended return, e-filing makes this much easier.

The exception: If you're filing a very old tax return (more than 2-3 years old), you may need to mail it since e-filing typically only works for current and recent prior years.

Filing Status: Why It Matters More Than You Think

Your filing status determines your tax rates, standard deduction amount, and eligibility for certain credits. Choosing the wrong one can cost you hundreds or thousands of dollars.

Single

For unmarried individuals with no dependents. Standard deduction is the lowest tier.

Married Filing Jointly

For married couples filing together. Nearly double the standard deduction of single filers. Access to most credits.

Married Filing Separately

For married couples who choose to file separately. Higher tax rates, limited credits.

Head of Household

For unmarried individuals who pay more than half the household expenses and have a qualifying dependent living with them for more than half the year. Standard deduction is higher than single but lower than married filing jointly.

Qualifying Widow(er)

For surviving spouses of someone who died in the past two years (only applicable for specific years following the death).

The key: If you're single and supporting a household, investigate Head of Household status. It often results in significant tax savings compared to filing as single.

Making Your Decision: A Simple Framework

Choose DIY if:

  • Your tax situation is straightforward
  • You enjoy learning and researching
  • You want to save money
  • You have time to invest in preparation

Hire a professional if:

  • Your situation is complex
  • You own a business or have significant investment income
  • You want to maximize deductions and minimize taxes
  • You value your time more than the professional fee
  • You're unsure about your obligations or status options

The Bottom Line

There's no shame in either choice. Filing your own taxes can work well if your situation is straightforward and you're willing to invest the time to do it correctly. Hiring a professional makes sense if complexity warrants it or if the fee is justified by the time and tax savings they provide.

Whatever you choose, the most important things are:

  1. File on time. Late filing results in penalties and interest.

  2. File accurately. Errors can trigger audits, penalties, and interest charges.

  3. Don't leave money on the table. Claim every deduction and credit you're entitled to.

  4. Keep records. Maintain documentation for at least three years in case of audit.

  5. Plan ahead. Don't wait until the last day. The earlier you file, the sooner you resolve your tax situation.

Whether you go the DIY route or hire a professional, the goal is the same: accurate, timely tax filing that ensures you're paying what you owe—no more, no less.

Back to blog
Tags: